Skip to main content

If password expiration is applied, should door-lockslock expiration be applied too?

After reading some topics in thereon here about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown uparose in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' keykeys also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, soe.g., lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopersfirefighters or so), vaults, etc.

For physical key-key basedbased door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back, and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even thothough it still requirerequires all employee with anemployees that are allowed access to do the upgrade one way or another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such a case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such a policy applied in some companies, standards, etc., or is thatit just a dumb idea I gothad?


Edit:

IMO, it indeed seems quiet anlike quite a heavy process (more something you do after you know a key has been compromised), but maybe you are aware of high risk-risk companies or specific companies that doesdo such rotation? Then, for what reasons (if both are not confidential!)?

If password expiration is applied, should door-locks expiration be applied too?

After reading some topics in there about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown up in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' key also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, so lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopers or so), vaults, etc.

For physical-key based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even tho it still require all employee with an allowed access to do the upgrade one way another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such policy applied in some companies, standards, etc or is that just a dumb idea I got?


Edit:

IMO it indeed seems quiet an heavy process (more something you do after you know a key has been compromised), but maybe you are aware of high risk companies or specific companies that does such rotation? Then, for what reasons (if both are not confidential!)?

If password expiration is applied, should door-lock expiration be applied too?

After reading some topics on here about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question arose in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' keys also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, e.g., lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for firefighters or so), vaults, etc.

For physical key-based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back, and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even though it still requires all employees that are allowed access to do the upgrade one way or another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such a case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such a policy applied in some companies, standards, etc., or is it just a dumb idea I had?


Edit:

IMO, it indeed seems like quite a heavy process (more something you do after you know a key has been compromised), but maybe you are aware of high-risk companies or specific companies that do such rotation? Then, for what reasons (if both are not confidential!)?

Became Hot Network Question
Tweeted twitter.com/StackSecurity/status/1197530123395850240
added 278 characters in body
Source Link
Xenos
  • 1.4k
  • 1
  • 10
  • 19

After reading some topics in there about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown up in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' key also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, so lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopers or so), vaults, etc.

For physical-key based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even tho it still require all employee with an allowed access to do the upgrade one way another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such policy applied in some companies, standards, etc or is that just a dumb idea I got?


Edit:

IMO it indeed seems quiet an heavy process (more something you do after you know a key has been compromised), but maybe you are aware of high risk companies or specific companies that does such rotation? Then, for what reasons (if both are not confidential!)?

After reading some topics in there about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown up in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' key also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, so lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopers or so), vaults, etc.

For physical-key based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even tho it still require all employee with an allowed access to do the upgrade one way another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such policy applied in some companies, standards, etc or is that just a dumb idea I got?

After reading some topics in there about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown up in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' key also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, so lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopers or so), vaults, etc.

For physical-key based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even tho it still require all employee with an allowed access to do the upgrade one way another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such policy applied in some companies, standards, etc or is that just a dumb idea I got?


Edit:

IMO it indeed seems quiet an heavy process (more something you do after you know a key has been compromised), but maybe you are aware of high risk companies or specific companies that does such rotation? Then, for what reasons (if both are not confidential!)?

Source Link
Xenos
  • 1.4k
  • 1
  • 10
  • 19

If password expiration is applied, should door-locks expiration be applied too?

After reading some topics in there about password expiration, and also after reading this comment, a question shown up in my mind: if we apply password expiration for the safety of users, should our door locks' key also expire?

By door lock, I mean any physical restriction access we might have, so lock(s) on the server room door, on the company's building entries (including maybe the backdoor for fire troopers or so), vaults, etc.

For physical-key based door locks, this would mean issuing a new metal key every X months/days/whatever, get the old key back and provide the new key to users (assuming they still are allowed to open the door). Sounds pretty heavy and complex, but it might help against copied keys or so.

For electronic-based door locks, this would mean reissuing new passwords/key accesses so the RFID/whatever card would need an upgrade with the new access key. Sounds lighter to do, even tho it still require all employee with an allowed access to do the upgrade one way another. Here, I assume the electronic card holds a "session token" somehow, not a never-changing user ID that the lock would compare to a database of allowed users (in such case, the user ID itself on both card and DB would need to be rotated).

So, is such policy applied in some companies, standards, etc or is that just a dumb idea I got?