I will be using CSE for a web application as follows.

  • Generate a random AES key
  • Encrypt the cleartext data with this AES key
  • Encrypt the AES key with the service's public key, using RSA

Obviously, all that will happen over SSL. I purposely skipped the process of how I retrieve the service's public key.

1) Is this algorithm secure? I assume it is because it seems to be the standard. Assuming of course you are correctly using AES and using a RSA key of a proper length.

2) I know that when encrypting a message using RSA, a padding algorithm such as RSA-OAEP should be used to add randomness to the message. But since in this case the message is random (it is the randomly generated AES key), is the padding algorithm still necessary / useful? If yes, why? Assuming here that the randomly generated AES key is random enough.


  • I'm struggling to understand why you wouldn't simply encrypt the clear text data with the public key that you have? What is the purpose for the (seemingly) superfluous step of AES encryption? – Tim Ebenezer Nov 24 '16 at 11:38
  • 1
    RSA doesn't allow you to encrypt more than ~240 bytes of data – christophetd Nov 24 '16 at 11:59
  • Why do you want to do this? What threats are you hoping to protect against? What security properties are you expecting this scheme to have? We can't answer if it will be secure or not without knowing these things. – Xander May 15 '17 at 14:29

1) It could be, yes. See also Is this RSA/AES combination good? and should I be using RSA or AES?

2) Yes. See What specific padding weakness does OAEP address in RSA?

It looks like you are trying to implement your own crypto. This is a bad idea. Furthermore, you mention you already have an SSL connection, so I don't really see the point of adding additional encryption on top of that.

If you really want this, you should use a higher-level interface. If you use GPG or SSL you don't have to worry about padding or combining RSA and AES.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.