If I connect a portable router like GL-AR150 to a public, unsecured Wi-Fi network at a hotel and create my own private, password-protected Wi-Fi network, how much more secure is this compared to just connecting straight to the hotel network?

Is there any added benefit to having the router instead connect to a VPN? I'm only concerned with preventing snooping unencrypted data, not necessarily changing my IP address.

  • Well, a router is a router, it doesn't provide much security. However, additional firewall features in the router (which is a norm inside most consumer grade router ) if configured properly, will give you some protection, but definitely not data encryption that prevent snooping, etc MiTM attack. – mootmoot Aug 10 at 8:09
  • curious question comes to mind: how do you plug WiFi into an Ethernet WAN jack? – dandavis Aug 10 at 19:47

If you connect your router to the hotels network, two things can happen:

Network Bridge

In this case, your device behaves as a bridge to the actual network. This doesn't really add any security at all, as it just passes packages into the network. Any device connecting to your bridge effectively connects to the original hotel network.

NAT mode

This is more likely going to happen and probably what you are asking about. Your router creates a private network, your devices can connect to. The router controls this network which is different from the hotel's network.

Any package passed from your device D to the router R is treated the following way:

  • D looks up the destination IP and notices that it's not in its network
  • D sends the package to its configured gateway R
  • R notices that the destination IP is not in a network it's directly connected to and therefore intents to send it to its gateway, the hotels router/gateway.
  • R runs in NAT-mode. Therefore D's package is masqueraded before being sent.
  • R modifies the packages sender information to contain its own MAC and IP (IP is R's IP in the hotel network)
  • An answer to this package take the same route vice versa. R receives it, changes the destination information to D in its private network and passes it to D.

The security benefit is, that none of the devices outside of your routers private network can see any device in it, except the router itself. While this prevents attacks targeting your devices directly, your router can still be attacked. In addition, this does NOT encrypt your traffic by default. Your router still sends your data through the hotel's network, just like your device gave it to your router.

Using a VPN encrypts everything you send, even while it travels through the hotel's network until it reaches the VPN gateway. If this is your objective, your router alone is not sufficient.

Your options are either using a VPN, encrypted Proxy connection (SOCKS for example) or strictly enforcing HTTPS (or another encryption) on every connection you use (which is rather tricky).

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.