• a public web service with enabled SSL/TLS
  • the web service enforces authentication using JSON Web Tokens
  • a client on a LAN without an Internet connection
  • a proxy on the LAN that grants point-to-point connections to mentioned web service


  • I want to connect to the proxy in order to access the web services
  • and I discuss with security folks what I have in mind


  • Security folks (experts/consultants) usually recommend additional authentication with the local proxy
  • I think of possible threat scenarios
  • I think the recommendation must be copied from some generic security guideline
  • I don't see a huge security benefit as authentication is already present but happens at the end of the tunnel

My reflections so far:

  • Even when I do not see huge benefits, an additional layer increases security
  • Then: more complex solutions are more error-prone. Errors may decrease security
  • A hypothetical attack to the web service (think of DoS) from the LAN would look as if it originates from the proxy and maybe it cannot be linked to a client IP.

But maybe I have missed something. So that's why I ask for a different angle to look at this matter. Maybe someone can point me in the right direction and could show me a risk that absolutely mandates to enable authentication on the proxy. Thanks in advance!


You must log in to answer this question.