There are several posts here about how easy it is to spoof caller ID and that there is no way to detect it.

I did find one post suggesting the calls to 1-800 numbers could not be spoofed.

being done by forwarding calls to a toll-free number, which then (by virtue of being toll-free) receives the true calling number through ANI (which is distinct from Caller ID and which supposedly cannot be spoofed) and finally forwards back to the original number. Source

Question: Why can't spoofed caller ID's be identified for everyone?

Related posts:


There are substantial flaws in the way phone routing works that makes this difficult.

Caller ID is specified by the outgoing call and anybody who has control over a phone branch exchange (PBX) can mess with it. (This is a "feature" so e.g. a support center can always have the same callback number as opposed to the number of the associate calling you.) I believe there is some limited ability to traverse the call routing, but that stops as soon as it hits a voice-over-IP provider (VoIP), which effectively provide a screen akin to reputation hijacking (an attacker gets lost in the noise of a shared pool of resources).

I am under the impression most spam calls come from VoIP, but my spam expertise is limited to email.

Happily, at least for the US, STIR/SHAKEN was just adopted, as announced by the Federal Communications Commission in Mandating STIR/SHAKEN to Combat Spoofed Robocalls.

With strict limitations on Caller ID forgery, endpoint anti-spam can then build blacklists of at least VoIP spammers.

From the FCC's news release PDF:


Industry-wide Deployment of STIR/SHAKEN Will Yield Substantial Benefits for American Consumers

WASHINGTON, March 31, 2020—The Federal Communications Commission today adopted new rules requiring implementation of caller ID authentication using technical standards known as “STIR/SHAKEN.” These rules will further the FCC’s efforts to protect consumers against malicious caller ID “spoofing,” which is often used during robocall scam campaigns to trick consumers into answering their phones.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.