I recently came across this website talking about sha1 padding attack.


After reading here are some of my doubts:

  1. How do the server side checks the signature? Even after successful padding, the sha1 hash is still different from the validate signature isn't it?

For example:
secretkey = key1
username = shaun
role = 1
sha1 hash : b7de8c16d9f42394b51e0c1c86c36a4b9bca8d49

secretkey = key1
username = shaun
role = 0
sha1 hash : 4e86a40776a282816ee0654cb2ec8a3fb2bd25e5

Can someone please explain to me which part do I get it wrongly? Thanks a lot :)


In this example, the server code looks like this:

Incoming value is "X|Y" -> split between "X" and "Y"
Compute id = Un-Base64(X)
Compute h = SHA-1(secret_key + id)
If the hexadecimal value of h is not equal to Y, then deny access
id is "user|role" with "role" being either 0 or 1; so, if id ends with "|0",
grant administrator access.

secret_key, of course, is unknown to the attacker. But the attacker can try to guess the length of that key, if only by trying different lengths; in that example, secret_key has length 25 bytes.

SHA-1 suffers from the length extension attack (like all Merkle–Damgård hash functions). See this answer for detailed explanations; bottom-line is that by knowing the length of secret_key, the attacker can compute a special "id" string like this:

id2 = aaaa|1somebytes|0

where somebytes include the SHA-1 standard padding, and then the attacker can compute the appropriate hash value for that "id", starting with the known SHA-1 value (the one for aaaa|1) and without knowing secret_key (that's the point of the "length extension attack": computing h(m') where m' starts with an unknown m, but with h(m) known).

The server will believe the provided "id" string to be genuine, and grant administrator rights to a user named "aaaa|1somebytes".

  • Hey, sorry just wondering if hmac was used then this a recommended implementation in the real world? – ysj Apr 28 '13 at 5:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.