I understand that copyright holders can identify illegal filesharing over BitTorrent by simply taking part in the sharing process and noting IPs of peers.

But how do they detect illegal downloads from file hosters?

  • Can you provide a source for your claim that copyright holders can detect downloads via file sharing sites? Context is relevant because if the claim is in relation to downloading executable files, users who may have been also using BitTorrent, or users of ISPs that are also content owners then the answer will vary significantly. – thexacre Jul 20 '14 at 10:30
  • All the context I have is that users downloading from RapidShare and similar services have received cease and desist letters ("Abmahnung") in Germany. So obviously they must somehow hove gotten the users' IPs. – user30615 Jul 20 '14 at 10:54
  • It'd help to edit your question to specify that you're speaking about Germany. What copyright holders do depends very much on how much initiative / leeway from the commoners' law they're allowed to take. – Steve Dodier-Lazaro Jul 20 '14 at 12:42
  • My question is not limited to Germany. – user30615 Jul 20 '14 at 13:35
  • ISP plays the role here imo – hoa Jul 20 '14 at 13:50

If you use a public hosting service, that service could of course also keep track of what it's hosting and who uploaded and downloaded it.

If the filehost is not a honeypot, if you use an unsecured or semisecured connection with a known protocol to transfer your files, the ISP could track whenever you initiate a file transfer. If the protocol works with an open checksum, the ISP could take that checksum and compare it to one of its databases. If they find a match, they have strong evidence that something that wasn't supposed to be shared was shared.

Now this could also work for encrypted file sharing systems such as the one hosted by MEGA, if the ISP got a hold of the keys and inspected the file, deemed it illegal, and then started tracking whoever is downloading it. (this is not hard considering most people leave the keys in the link - the ISP could backtrace your steps and inspect the pages for the hashtag keys, or defer that task to a crawling service (would probably be faster))

Alternatively, a shill (cop, digital rights holder, etc) could transfer you the files or request that you transfer the files and then rat you out.

Beyond that, a spying agency, a bored hacker or anyone being able to install software on your device (e.g. the company you have your operating system from) could have installed spyware on your computer to track what you are doing.

Finally, somebody could be looking over your shoulder.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy